
I stayed up late last night because I wanted to finish the Two-at-once, Toe-up Socks...
Well, I did finish but then I realized that my socks' looked really odd... Most importantly, they just won't fit on my feet as the heel is not deep enough!
Look at the photo! Isn't that a bizarre look?
[Click on photos to enlarge]
I went to bed at 03:00am, completely disgusted and exhausted, wondering what went wrong... I have read and reread the pattern several times and I don't see what I did differently than it was instructed... Still don't today with a refreshed mind... ???

I am afraid I am going to have to rip off that messy and weird looking heel and to redo it following the Socknitters's Toe-Up Afterthought Heel Socks lesson this time, meaning working the heel like the toe shaping on regular socks.
I thought that the Knit Picks pattern was instructing for a heel made like a top down sock but I was wrong. This afterthought heel is supposed to be made like the top of a hat, making the decreasing swirl counter-clockwise on the heel.
Definetely NOT the photo illustrating the Knit Picks pattern, by the way! The toe is different on their photo as well as the cuff...
I might redo the cuffing too, making the Stockinette part higher than 1 inch as instructed, and how it is on the pattern's photo also. It should be less tricky to rib the cuff this time as the afterthought heel scrap yarn is not linking the 2 socks together anymore... My yarn got tangled previously!
I thought that making the Geisha socks was my worst sock knitting experience but at least the pattern was matching the photo! My struggling back then was due to the fact that I was using solid color yarn (making my laddering problem pretty obvious) and to my inexperience with 2 circular needles!
What I have learned with this pattern: - There are 2 different kinds of Afterthought heels! The "Top down toe decrease" and the "top of hat decrease". I haven't tried the first one but I pitifully failed on the second one! I cannot really imagine how cute a sock heel could look cute as imitating the top of a hat though... - I did much better with 2 circular needles. No laddering! :) - I kind of like making 2 socks at once although using 2 skeins of yarn can be a little messy sometimes.
I think I like making Top Down Socks better than Top-Up Socks. My next pair of socks might be a Two-at-Once, Top Down... but for now, I'd better stop "waisting my time" here (as my DH says - He knows what is best...) and find a way to fix those socks!